Guy Carbonneau was a good hockey and was a role-player for 3 Cup winning teams, but if you look at the ten most similar players to him, there's not a single Hall of Fame player among them:
Far too many times over the years, the HHOF committee have proven themselves to be people of rare intelligence: it's rare that they show any.
The Hockey Hall of Fame, brought to you by Cracker Barrel.
Where if it don't move, we'll fry it and shove it on a plate and tell people with no palate and can't cook worth a damn that it tastes just like home. Oh, and we'll stick random people in the Hall and tell all the "casual hockey fans" that don't know s### other than "ooh, that shootout is fun!" that they were great.