WordsOfWisdom Posted March 7, 2015 Share Posted March 7, 2015 Anaheim: Teemu SelanneArizona: Dale HawerchukBoston: Bobby OrrBuffalo: Dominik HasekCalgary: Lanny MacDonaldCarolina: Ron FrancisChicago: Bobby Hull (after a battle with Mikita)Colorado: Peter Statsny (Sakic and Roy were candidates too)Columbus: Rick NashDallas: Mike ModanoDetroit: Gordie HoweEdmonton: Wayne GretzkyFlorida: Pavel BureLos Angeles: Marcel Dionne (honorable mention to Robitaille and Blake)Minnesota: Marian GaborikMontreal: Maurice RichardNashville: Shea WeberNew Jersey: Martin BrodeurNew York Islanders: Denis Potvin (though Bossy and Trottier could stake a claim as well)New York Rangers: Brian Leetch (close between him and Mess)Ottawa: Daniel AlfredssonPhiladelphia: Bobby ClarkePittsburgh: Mario LemieuxSan Jose: Joe ThorntonSt. Louis: Brett HullTampa Bay: Martin St. LouisToronto: Frank MahovlichVancouver: Trevor Linden (tough call between him and Bure)Washington: Alexander OvechkinWinnipeg: Ilya Kovalchuk (Hawerchuk belongs to the Coyotes if we're doing this by franchise) I notice there aren't many defencemen in these lists. ie: New Jersey: Scott Stevens St. Louis: Chris Pronger Detroit: Nicklas Lidstrom Maybe we should do a best player at each position (L, C, R, D, G), for each NHL team, of all time. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ScottM Posted March 7, 2015 Share Posted March 7, 2015 I notice there aren't many defencemen in these lists. ie: New Jersey: Scott Stevens St. Louis: Chris Pronger Detroit: Nicklas Lidstrom Maybe we should do a best player at each position (L, C, R, D, G), for each NHL team, of all time. That's true. I realized that when I was typing the list. I had 4, iirc. I didn't have time to do it when I made my original list, but it did occur to me that F, D, and G done separately might be a good idea. I like yours better though. I'm going to try that when I have the time. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
JagerMeister Posted March 7, 2015 Author Share Posted March 7, 2015 I notice there aren't many defencemen in these lists. ie: New Jersey: Scott Stevens St. Louis: Chris Pronger Detroit: Nicklas Lidstrom Maybe we should do a best player at each position (L, C, R, D, G), for each NHL team, of all time. good idea WOW. Unfortunately, cant change the title though Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ScottM Posted March 8, 2015 Share Posted March 8, 2015 Here are my all time teams: Anaheim Paul Kariya Ryan Getzlaf Teemu Selanne Scott Niedermeyer Francois Beauchemin Jean-Sebastien Gigeure Arizona Keith Tkachuk Dale Hawerchuk Shane Doan Teppo Numminen Randy Carlisle Sean Burke Boston Johnny Bucyk Phil Esposito Cam Neely Bobby Orr Ray Borque Frank Brimsek Buffalo Dave Andreychuk Gilbert Perrault Miroslav Satan Phil Housley Alexei Zhitnik Dominik Hasek Calgary Eric Vail Joe Nieuwendyk Lanny MacDonald Al MacInnis Gary Suter Miikka Kiprusoff Carolina Sylvain Turgeon Ron Francis Blaine Stoughton Glen Wesley Adam Burt Cam Ward Chicago Steve Larmer Stan Mikita Bobby Hull Chris Chelios Doug Wilson Tony Esposito Colorado Michel Goulet Peter Statsny Milan Hejduk Adam Foote Rob Blake Patrick Roy Columbus Rick Nash R. J. Umberger David Vyborny Rotislav Klesla Fedor Tyutin Sergei Bobrovsky Dallas Brian Bellows Mike Modano Dino Ciccarelli Sergei Zubov Derian Hatcher Ed Belfour Detroit Ted Lindsay Steve Yzerman Gordie Howe Nicklas Lidstrom Marcel Pronovost Terry Sawchuk Edmonton Esa Tikkanen Wayne Gretzky Jarri Kurri Paul Coffey Paul Coffey Grant Fuhr Florida Ray Whitney Olli Jokinen Pavel Bure Robert Svehla Jay Bouwmeester Roberto Luongo Los Angeles Luc Robitaille Marcel Dionne Dave Taylor Rob Blake Lubomir Visnovsky Rogie Vachon Minnesota Zach Parise Mikko Koivu Marian Gaborik Nick Schultz Filip Kuba Niklas Backstrom Montreal Aurele Joliat Jean Beliveau Maurice Richard Doug Harvey Larry Robinson Jacques Plantes Nashville Scott Hartnell David Legwand Martin Erat Shea Weber Ryan Suter Pekka Rinne New Jersey Patrick Elias Bobby Holik John MacLean Scott Stevens Scott Niedermeyer Martin Brodeur New York Islanders Clark Gillies Bryan Trottier Mike Bossy Dennis Potvin Ken Morrow Billy Smith New York Rangers Adam Graves Mark Messier Rod Gilbert Brian Leetch Harry Howell Henrik Lundqvist Ottawa Dany Heatley Jason Spezza Daniel Alfredsson Chris Phillips Wade Redden Craig Anderson Philadephia Brian Propp Bobby Clarke Mark Recchi Joe Watson Eric Desjardins Bernie Parent Pittsburgh Kevin Stevens Mario Lemieux Jaromir Jagr Ron Stackhouse Kris Letang Tom Barrasso San Jose Jeff Friesen Joe Thornton Owen Nolan Dan Boyle Brad Stuart Evgeni Nabakov St. Louis Pavol Demitra Bernie Federko Brett Hull Chris Pronger Al MacInnis Curtis Joseph Tampa Bay Fredrik Modin Vincent Lecavalier Martin St. Louis Dan Boyle Roman Hamrlik Nikolai Khabibulin Toronto Frank Mahovlic Darryl Sittler George Armstrong Tim Horton Borje Salmig Turk Broda Vancouver Daniel Sedin Henrik Sedin Trevor Linden Mattias Ohlund Jyrki Lumme Roberto Luongo Washington Alexander Ovechkin Nicklas Backstrom Peter Bondra Scott Stevens Sergei Gonchar Olaf Kolzig Winnipeg Ilya Kovalchuk Marc Savard Marian Hossa Tobias Enstrom Dustin Byfuglien Kari Lehtonen Montreal was the hardest. There were a lot of tough position battles there. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
WordsOfWisdom Posted March 8, 2015 Share Posted March 8, 2015 Here are my all time teams: AnaheimPaul Kariya Ryan Getzlaf Teemu Selanne Scott Niedermeyer Francois BeaucheminJean-Sebastien Gigeure Arizona Keith Tkachuk Jeremy Roenick Shane Doan Teppo Numminen Randy Carlisle Sean Burke Boston Johnny Bucyk Phil Esposito Cam Neely Bobby Orr Ray Borque Frank Brimsek Buffalo Dave Andreychuk Gilbert Perrault Alexander Mogilny Phil Housley Alexei Zhitnik Dominik Hasek Calgary Eric Vail Joe Nieuwendyk Theoren Fleury Al MacInnis Gary Suter Miikka Kiprusoff Carolina Sylvain Turgeon Ron Francis Blaine Stoughton Glen Wesley Adam Burt Cam Ward Chicago Steve Larmer Stan Mikita Bobby Hull Chris Chelios Doug Wilson Ed Belfour Colorado Michel Goulet Joe Sakic Milan Hejduk Adam Foote Rob Blake Patrick Roy Columbus Rick Nash R. J. Umberger David Vyborny Rotislav Klesla Fedor Tyutin Sergei Bobrovsky Dallas Brian Bellows Mike Modano Dino Ciccarelli Sergei Zubov Derian Hatcher Ed Belfour Detroit Ted Lindsay Steve Yzerman Gordie Howe Nicklas Lidstrom Marcel Pronovost Terry Sawchuk Edmonton Esa Tikkanen Wayne Gretzky Jarri Kurri Paul Coffey Paul Coffey Grant Fuhr Florida Ray Whitney Olli Jokinen Pavel Bure Robert Svehla Jay Bouwmeester Roberto Luongo Los Angeles Luc Robitaille Marcel Dionne Dave Taylor Rob Blake Lubomir Visnovsky Rogie Vachon Minnesota Zach Parise Mikko Koivu Marian Gaborik Nick Schultz Filip Kuba Niklas Backstrom Montreal Aurele Joliat Jean Beliveau Maurice Richard Doug Harvey Larry Robinson Jacques Plantes Nashville Scott Hartnell David Legwand Martin Erat Shea Weber Ryan Suter Pekka Rinne New Jersey Patrick Elias Bobby Holik John MacLean Scott Stevens Scott Niedermeyer Martin Brodeur New York Islanders Clark Gillies Bryan Trottier Mike Bossy Dennis Potvin Ken Morrow Billy Smith New York Rangers Adam Graves Mark Messier Rod Gilbert Brian Leetch Harry Howell Henrik Lundqvist Ottawa Dany Heatley Jason Spezza Daniel Alfredsson Chris Phillips Wade Redden Craig Anderson Philadephia Brian Propp Eric Lindros Mark Recchi Joe Watson Eric Desjardins Bernie Parent Pittsburgh Kevin Stevens Mario Lemieux Jaromir Jagr Ron Stackhouse Kris Letang Tom Barrasso San Jose Jeff Friesen Joe Thornton Owen Nolan Dan Boyle Brad Stuart Evgeni Nabakov St. Louis Pavol Demitra Bernie Federko Brett Hull Chris Pronger Al MacInnis Curtis Joseph Tampa Bay Fredrik Modin Vincent Lecavalier Martin St. Louis Dan Boyle Roman Hamrlik Nikolai Khabibulin Toronto Frank Mahovlic Doug Gilmour Alexander Mogilny Tim Horton Borje Salmig Curtis Joseph Vancouver Daniel Sedin Henrik Sedin Pavel Bure Mattias Ohlund Jyrki Lumme Roberto Luongo Washington Alexander Ovechkin Nicklas Backstrom Peter Bondra Scott Stevens Sergei Gonchar Olaf Kolzig Winnipeg Ilya Kovalchuk Marc Savard Marian Hossa Tobias Enstrom Dustin Byfuglien Kari Lehtonen Montreal was the hardest. There were a lot of tough position battles there. Nicely done! I made some modifications to your list in BOLD. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ScottM Posted March 8, 2015 Share Posted March 8, 2015 Nicely done! I made some modifications to your list in BOLD. If that's all we differ on, I'd say that's pretty remarkable. Lol Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
WordsOfWisdom Posted March 8, 2015 Share Posted March 8, 2015 If that's all we differ on, I'd say that's pretty remarkable. Lol Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.