I think most of us are saving judgement until we see him do something. It doesn't mean we're wanting him to do something just for the sake of doing so. But when he does, we'll feel like we'll realize what we have. So far, he's saying the kinds of things I guess you'd expect.
In MacTavish's case, the good ol' boys club were running the show in Edmonton. There still is a resistance among players to play in that city regardless of who else is there. But winning will probably solve those issues and so far Dave Tippet is doing a great job.