I don't think it should be banned although I can't say I'm a fan of "meaningless" fights (e.g. each team's goon throwing down for no reasin than just because), either. For me, it depends on the reason for a fight. I'm thinking back to the Hawks-Sharks game last season where Jamal Mayers (who is a better Hawks enforcer, in my opinion, than Dan Carcillo was) dropped the gloves with Raffi Torres during the first game Torres had against the Hawks since his hit on Marian Hossa (when he was with Phoenix, and during a playoff game, no less). I thought that was better than if Mayers had instead taken a cheap shot or made a dirty hit on Torres. Since then, I think the Hossa/Torres issue is done.