Your statement implies that it should have been more obvious that he should have played Ward. in the 2005/2006 regular season, Gerber had a .906 save percentage, while Ward had a .882. Neither goalie was particularly hot going into the playoffs, but without doing the math, I'd hazard to say that Gerber's numbers were probably slightly better. Gerber let up 6 goals on 21 shots in Game 1 against Montreal, then was pulled after giving up 3 in the first in Game 2. Ward was pulled after giving up four in the first 20:44 in Game 5 against NJ, but Laviolette went back to him for Game 5, which they won. Ward was again pulled in game 3 vs. Buffalo after looking shaky in the first two games of the series, and was reinserted in the middle of game 4. I'm not arguing that Laviolette is a great coach, I think he's a good coach, but going with Gerber to start the playoffs was what he should have done. And while Ward posted a .920 save percentage overall in the playoffs, he also posted individual game marks of .870, .765, .889, .842 (a game the 'Canes won, btw), .846, .862, .882, and .895 (also a W). That's a sub-.900 save percentage in over a third of his games played. He won some games for them, but he also lost a few. And there were a few the team won in spite of him.