As with the post addressed by Rodoran, and in reference to your quote, can you identify where I said Giroux sucked, or was a bust? In fact, I think i said, "Giroux will be fine." I think anytime a player is playing below his potential, criticism is warranted. there are two real possibilities here... 1) giroux is a good player having a sub par season, 2) Giroux had a great season which is not the norm, and what we are seeing now is. I don't think its the latter, and therefore, criticism is warranted. I think he is trying to hard to make the perfect pass and is reluctant to shoot. He should be a little more selfish. I am totally on board with Rad's point of view here, I won't be gettinng myslef all spun up over Giroux having a hat trick agaisnt the Islanders or becasue he sprawls out trying to keep the puck in the zone. As a fan, I expect him to be the best player on this team and the captain. I tune in to each game expecting to see the player that earned that position, not another reminder of it being the wrong decision. You cite Richards and make the point that he was compared to Clarke too soon, and unjustifiably so, and therefore you aer sensitive about it. By the same token I compare Giroux to Richards with the same sensitivity, worried that this team is going to run another promising star right out of town