Pre-season, I had both teams sniffing around the playoff picture as a bubble team.
If things fall right, either could make it in, if they go not so right, they fall right out.
That said, as was mentioned, I really do like Vancouver's overall depth compared to Buffalo's and their goaltending seems to be more solid and stable.
Granted, Jacob Markstrom is in a contract year and we all know how that goes sometimes (plays like Superman, gets a big payday, goes back to being Clark Kent after that), but still, his play in the nets can't be denied and his backup, Thatcher Demko, has been playing just as well....and the Canucks seem to have those guys almost in a timeshare in goal too.
Over in Bison Land, the goaltending is a bit more sketchy with both Hutton and Ullmark.
Linus hasn't broken through like I thought he would, although there is certainly plenty of time for that to happen this year, and Hutton has looked good on some nights, very mediocre on others.
Reason I harp on the goalies so much on both is because I think their offenses will run hot n cold and it will be the guys between the pipes that will have much to say in whether they make the playoffs or not.
So I have both as playoff bubble teams trending upwards, but neither will be winning their division nor a Conference title this year, and neither will be able to withstand significant injuries at this stage of their developments.
One other thing to consider when trying to decide how "real" either of these teams are:
Even if both do well and squeak into the playoffs, both rosters have lots of UFA;s and RFA's on them.
The decisions each GM makes will determine whether this year and going into next and beyond will continue their development and contender status...……...or cause them to start over again with fresh faces as they take one step backwards next year, in order to take two forward after that.
Who do they keep? Who do they let go? Of those they keep, can contracts be kept reasonable to ice a competitive team year after year?
Will the core each has in place be able to elevate and/or benefit from the supplemental talent signed or kept on board?
So really, this year may not be the telling year as to whether the teams are for real or not......but next one might.