No. its the hall of fame not the hall of very good. Marleau has never been on the radar for any major award EVER. He was just a solid dependable compiler who would get looks for the lady bing ever year for playing such a no touch game. A game which despite people lauding his playoff goals, was not good in the playoffs. Roenick had it right when he said "if he had half my heart or I had Half his talent, it would have been a top all time player"
I don't even agree with Cam Neely being in there despite being the prototypical power forward who got hitting from behind its own penalty and he was my favorite player growing up.
Thornton on the other hand is a lock for 1st Ballot even with his lack of playoff success. A top 6 finalist for the hart 5 times in his career, sometimes outscoring his next closest teammate by over 50%, turning chicken **** into chicken salad. if Thornton played in the 80's its highly likely he is 2nd in all time assists behind Gretzky. He lost a year and a half of his prime to lockouts and sits at 1098 assists in 7th place all time while doing it in mostly low scoring era and he never really had major injuries until the last few years when both his knees got blown out. Ron Francis is #2 with 1249 lol. He is also one of 3 players to ever hit back to back 90 assist seasons. The other 2 are named Gretzky and Lemieux lol
Edit: jeez. he is even 14th in all time POINTS, despite playing in a mostly low scoring era.