You know at the time I didn't have a problem with it, but that was some other assumptions being made which don't look like they are working out. At the time: I was assuming that Hartnell/Giroux/Voracek was actually going to be our first line. That hasn't worked in any way shape or form. I was assuming that Schenn could actually make the transition to 2nd line LW. That hasn't happened. A line of Schenn/Vinnie/Simmonds was supposed to be a competent 2nd line. That hasn't worked out. Now that none of that has happened it looks REALLY bad, and I mean REALLY bad. Schenn must be at center in order to be what it is we want him to develop into. Vinnie isn't effective at the wing either. What does that mean? At this point, yes this signing would be a mistake.